Thrift-Store Christmas Record Night - Social & Community quest for Beginner level adventurers

Thrift-Store Christmas Record Night

Who will find the strangest Santa in the bargain bin?

Share:

Your mission

The Bargain Bin Jingle Jury

Everyone hunts down one Christmas album on vinyl or CD for $5 or less and plays one song from it for the group. Then the jury sticks its votes on the covers, and you announce the Best Song and Most Baffling Cover champions out loud to a big round of applause.

Bonus challenge: Before each song plays, everyone guesses out loud what it will sound like just from the cover. Closest guess gets first pick of the leftover cookies.

Saves it to your list, no account needed.
Time
2–3 hours
Cost
Supplies only
Each person spends up to $5 on an album. If nobody owns a player, a basic CD player runs about $20–40 and a simple record player about $50–100.
3 supplies · see the gear
Who it's for
friends, family, date night, a group · All ages; kids 8+ will love the cover voting
Level
Beginner
Where
Both
Season
Fall-Winter
Thrift stores usually put out holiday music from November through December, so shop early for the best picks.

About This Quest

Grab a few friends, raid the thrift store for Christmas albums under $5, then bring your finds home and play one song from each. Expect crooning uncles in matching sweaters, a polka sleigh ride, and covers so odd you will need a vote.

Somewhere in a dusty bin, a 1970s organ trio in tinsel bow ties is waiting for you. Thrift stores are packed with forgotten holiday albums, and every one has a story on the cover. Each friend picks one record or CD for $5 or less, and then you take turns playing a song for the room. You don't need to know anything about music, just a good eye for weird. The night ends with a vote.

Why This Quest Matters

Holiday music is usually the same ten songs on repeat. Here you get to hear the ones that got left behind, from the choir that sang a little too loud to the cowboy who yodeled through Silent Night. Laughing at them together is its own tradition. Somebody's grandma loved that album once, and tonight you get to love it too.

What You'll Experience

  • Hunt the bargain bins: Flip through crates of forgotten Christmas albums and find your secret treasure.
  • Unveil your cover: Hold up your find and watch your friends try not to laugh.
  • Hear a surprise song: Discover a holiday tune you never knew existed, maybe one you secretly love.
  • Crown the winners: Vote for the best song and the most baffling cover of the night.

What You'll Need

Top gear to make this quest great.

Pull it off

Portable CD player

Lets you play the CDs your friends bring home from the store.

4.4 (1,993)
Get on Amazon · $29.99 — Portable CD player
Record player

Brings those dusty old vinyl finds to life, crackles and all.

$59.99 — buy Record player on Amazon
Record cleaning brush

Clears off thrift-store dust so your songs play clearly.

$14.95 — buy Record cleaning brush on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices may change.

Before You Begin

Your only job is to bring a good eye and a sense of humor. Text your friends the plan and pick a thrift store or two to meet at. Essential: a CD player or record player, depending on what you find, and $5 per person. Handy extras: a record cleaning brush to wipe dust off old vinyl so it plays clearly, sticky notes for casting votes, and holiday cookies to keep the judges happy.

Step-by-Step Guide

1

Raid the Bargain Bins

45 min

Let the treasure hunt begin. Head to the thrift store together and find the music section, usually near the books. Look for anything with Christmas on it: crooners, choirs, polka bands, cartoon reindeer. Each person picks one album for $5 or less, and keep it secret if you can. Your player handles big 12-inch albums, smaller 10-inch ones and little 7-inch singles, so grab whatever size makes you grin. Check vinyl for big scratches and CDs for cracks before you pay.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Hold your pick behind your back at checkout so nobody sees your cover before the big reveal.
2

Set Up the Listening Room

15 min

Time to make it cozy. Back home, set your player where everyone can hear it, dim the lights, and put out snacks. Found a CD? Plug a CD player into the record player's Line input and it plays right through the same speakers. Gently wipe each record with the carbon fiber brush, moving in circles with the grooves. Its soft bristles lift dust without any cleaning liquid. Then put everyone's album face down in a pile so the covers stay a surprise until it's their turn.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Test the player with one album first so you know the volume and speed are right before the show.
3

The Great Cover Reveal

15 min

Here's where the giggles start. One at a time, flip your album over and show it to the room. Tell everyone where you found it and why you picked it. Is that Santa riding a dolphin? Why is the whole family wearing matching capes? Let your friends ask questions and make wild guesses about the music.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Read the back of the album out loud. The song titles and liner notes are often just as funny as the cover.
4

One Song Each

45 min

Now let's hear what these covers sound like. Each person picks one song from their album and plays it for the room. Check the label for the speed: most big albums spin at 33, small singles at 45, and old heavy ones at 78. Flip the switch to match so nobody sounds like a chipmunk. Listen to the whole thing, even if it's a ten-minute organ medley. Cheer, sing along, or dance if the mood strikes. Which song will everyone be humming on the way home?

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Pick a song you've never heard of instead of a classic. The surprises make the best moments.
5

Crown the Jingle Jury Winners

15 min

The votes are in your hands. Line up all the albums where everyone can see them. Each person writes their picks on sticky notes and sticks them on the winners: one for Best Song and one for Most Baffling Cover. You can't vote for your own. Count the notes and announce the champions with a big round of applause.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Let the winners pick the last song of the night, and play it loud.

You turned a handful of forgotten albums into the best concert of the season. Save the winning cover and bring it back next year so the champion can defend the title.

Get another side quest
Full gear guide
10 Community Mural Painting Supplies Worth Buying in 2026
See all picks →

Gear Up for Your Quest

You bring the curiosity. We've found the tools.

Pull it off

Portable CD player

Portable CD player

Lets you play the CDs your friends bring home from the store.

4.4 (1,993)
Get on Amazon · $29.99 — Portable CD playerwhat to look for & our pick →
+ complete the kit — 3 more
Record player

Record player

Recommended
$59.99
4.4 (55,603)

Brings those dusty old vinyl finds to life, crackles and all.

A basic turntable with built-in speakers.

Get on Amazon · $59.99 — Record playerwhat to look for & our pick →

Record cleaning brush
$14.95
4.6 (11,737)

Clears off thrift-store dust so your songs play clearly.

A soft brush made for wiping vinyl records.

Get on Amazon · $14.95 — Record cleaning brushwhat to look for & our pick →

Sticky notes

Sticky notes

Optional
$3–6

Makes voting fun as everyone sticks their picks right on the winning covers.

A pad of colorful sticky notes.

what to look for & our pick →

RELATED GEAR GUIDE

10 Community Mural Painting Supplies Worth Buying in 2026

Practical picks, real prices · Social & Community

As an Amazon Associate, IRL Sidequests earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Prices and availability are subject to change. The price shown at checkout on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.

Where this one naturally leads next.

Thrift-Store Secret Santa Storytime - Social & Community quest

Thrift-Store Secret Santa Storytime

Every chipped mug deserves a heroic past.

Gather your friends for a Secret Santa with a twist. Everyone gets $10 and one thrift shop to buy a gift. Then each giver tells the wildest made-up history of what's inside. That ceramic frog? It once guarded a pirate's lighthouse.

2–3 hoursFamilySupplies from $10
Beginner
View Quest
Thrift-Store Secret Santa Storytime
Blind Gift-Wrap Showdown - Social & Community quest

Blind Gift-Wrap Showdown

Can you make a bike pump look adorable?

Grab a few friends and one wonderfully awkward object, like a basketball or a bike pump. Everyone wraps the same thing with newspaper, twine and treasures from outside, backs turned and no peeking, before a 10-minute timer runs out. Then comes the big reveal, and the vote.

1 hourFamilyGear from $16
Beginner
View Quest
Blind Gift-Wrap Showdown
Advent Envelope Dare Line - Social & Community quest

Advent Envelope Dare Line

Every morning, a tiny dare with their name on it.

Make an advent countdown for someone you love, filled with dares instead of chocolate. Write 24 five-minute real-world challenges, tuck each into a numbered envelope and string them on a line by their door. Every morning they open one and do something small and fun, like waving at a stranger's dog.

1.5–2 hoursFamilyGear from $35
Beginner
View Quest
Advent Envelope Dare Line

Not this one?

Get a different side quest in 30 seconds

Tell the generator how much time you have, who you're with, and your mood — it picks from 500+ quests like this one.

Try the real life side quest generator

Or browse the full list of real-life side quest ideas or side quests to do with friends.

Your weekend just got more interesting.

One new adventure idea every Thursday — plus this quest saved to your account. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy policy.