Tabletop Firepit Night - Creative Arts quest for Beginner level adventurers

Tabletop Firepit Night

Pull up a chair, the marshmallows are almost gold

Share:

Your mission

The S'more Showdown

Toast a classic s'more for everyone at the table, then have each person build one invented version with an add-in. Taste them all and vote out loud on the table's favorite.

Bonus challenge: Give the winning combination a silly name and make it the house s'more for next time.

Saves it to your list, no account needed.
Time
2+ hours
Cost
Free with your own gear
Starter gear from $82
The firepit and long roasting sticks are one-time buys. Each night costs about $10–20 for fuel, marshmallows, chocolate, graham crackers and add-ins.
3 supplies · see the gear
Who it's for
friends, family, date night, a group · Kids 8+ can hold their own stick while seated with an adult beside them; an adult toasts for anyone younger
Level
Beginner
Where
Outdoor
Season
Year-round

About This Quest

Gather your favorite people around a little tabletop fire and spend an evening building s'mores. You'll toast marshmallows to a glossy gold, press them between chocolate and graham crackers, and invent flavors nobody at the table saw coming.

A flame about the size of a dinner plate sits in the middle of your table, everyone leans in, and the whole evening slows down to the speed of one marshmallow turning gold. You'll set up the firepit outside on a solid stone or metal surface, light it, and work through round after round of s'mores: the classic first, then your own strange and wonderful versions with sea salt, pecans or banana. Toasting takes a couple of minutes per marshmallow, so the only skill you need is patience. Your job tonight is to crown the table's favorite creation.

Why This Quest Matters

A tabletop fire does something no screen can: it gives everyone a reason to sit close and stay a while. The s'mores are sticky and delicious, but the best part is the easy talk that happens while you wait for a marshmallow to turn gold. Everyone at the table ends up a little closer than when they sat down.

What You'll Experience

  • Chase the perfect gold: Learn the slow rotate that melts a marshmallow to liquid inside without burning it.
  • Invent a wild s'more: Sea salt, pecans, banana slices, whatever your table dares you to try.
  • Warm the crackers: Hold them near the flame for ten seconds and taste the difference.
  • Crown a champion flavor: Let everyone vote on the best combination of the night.

What You'll Need

Top gear to make this quest great.

Pull it off

Tabletop firepit rated for cooking food

Gives you the steady, dinner-plate-sized flame you toast every marshmallow over.

Get on Amazon · $34.19 — Tabletop firepit rated for cooking food
Marshmallow Roaster

Thirty inches of handle keeps hands well back from the flame while the marshmallow toasts.

$27.95 — buy Marshmallow Roaster on Amazon
Fire extinguisher or water bucket

Stays within arm's reach of the table the entire time the fire is lit.

$19.97 — buy Fire extinguisher or water bucket on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices may change.

Before You Begin

Pick your spot before you buy a single marshmallow, because the right surface makes the whole night easy. You'll want a tabletop firepit the maker rates for cooking food over, the exact fuel its manual names, long metal roasting sticks (30 inches or so), and the s'mores basics: graham crackers, chocolate bars and marshmallows. Handy extras: a cutting board as a prep surface, add-ins like sea salt, pecans or banana, and a bucket of water or an extinguisher parked within arm's reach. If you're using a patio table, take the umbrella out first.

Safety Tips

A good quest stays a good story. These are general notes; your gear's manual, the venue's rules and local law come first.

  • Set the firepit outdoors only, on a stable nonflammable surface: concrete, stone, metal or bare ground. If it sits on a patio table, that table must be metal or stone, with the umbrella removed.
  • Keep the space above the flame completely clear. Never light it under an awning, umbrella, ceiling or tree branch.
  • Use only the fuel your firepit's manual specifies, and only roast food over a firepit the manufacturer rates for cooking. Never mix fuels or add lighter fluid.
  • Never add fuel to a hot or lit pit. Shut it down and let it cool fully first.
  • Keep a bucket of water or a fire extinguisher within arm's reach the whole time, and have an adult watching the flame from lighting to shutdown.
  • Everyone roasts sitting down with a long stick, and nobody runs past the table. After you extinguish, the metal stays hot for 30 minutes or more, so leave it alone until it's cool.

Step-by-Step Guide

1

Claim Your Fire Spot

20 min

Start outside, with nothing above you. Find a stable nonflammable surface: a concrete patio, a stone step, a metal table with the umbrella pulled out, or bare ground. Check that no awning, branch or ceiling hangs overhead. Assemble the firepit following its manual, then add only the fuel the manual names.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • If this is your first time with the firepit, do this part in daylight so you can read the manual easily.
2

Light It And Settle In

15 min

Light the firepit the way its instructions say, then step back and let the flame settle for a few minutes until it's steady and about the size of a dinner plate. Put your bucket of water or extinguisher within arm's reach. Now pull the chairs in close, so everyone can reach the fire while seated.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Seat the youngest roasters where an adult can reach their stick without standing up.
3

Build The S'more Bar

10 min

Set up a prep surface next to the fire, like a cutting board or tray. Break the chocolate bars into squares ahead of time so nobody fumbles with a hot marshmallow in one hand. Lay out graham crackers, marshmallows, and your add-ins: sea salt, chopped pecans, banana slices, whatever sounded fun at the store.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Put the chocolate squares in the shade or indoors until you need them, or they'll melt into one block.
4

Toast The Perfect Gold

25 min

Here's the one skill of the night. Skewer a marshmallow, hold it a few inches above the flame, not in it, and rotate it slowly. Give it a couple of minutes. When the whole surface turns even gold, the inside has gone liquid. Press it between chocolate and crackers and squeeze until the chocolate goes soft.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Want the burnt-sugar crust? Dip it into the flame for a second, pull it out, blow it out, and taste the difference against a gold one.
5

The S'more Showdown

25 min

Everyone builds one invented s'more using at least one add-in. Salted dark chocolate. Banana and pecan. Whatever sounds terrible but might be brilliant. Try warming the crackers near the flame for about ten seconds first, they get toasty and crisp. Then pass them around, taste every one, and vote out loud on the table's favorite.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Make a second round of the winner so everyone gets a full one. The vote is more fun when the prize is edible.
6

Shut It Down Properly

40 min

Extinguish the fire with your firepit's cover or shutoff, then leave it exactly where it is. The metal stays hot for 30 minutes or longer, so no packing up yet. Use that time for the last of the chocolate and the easy post-fire conversation, then pack the cooled firepit away.

💡 Pro Tips:

  • • Tell everyone the pit is still hot before you all drift away from the table, especially the kids.

You spent a whole evening building s'mores over your own little fire and let the table pick a winner. Make that winning flavor again next time and see if it defends the title.

Get another side quest
Full gear guide
10 Pieces of Cyanotype Sun Printing Gear Worth Buying in 2026
See all picks →

Gear Up for Your Quest

You bring the curiosity. We've found the tools.

Pull it off

Tabletop firepit rated for cooking food

Tabletop firepit rated for cooking food

Gives you the steady, dinner-plate-sized flame you toast every marshmallow over.

Get on Amazon · $34.19 — Tabletop firepit rated for cooking fooddetails & deals →
+ complete the kit — 3 more
Marshmallow Roaster

Marshmallow Roaster

EssentialPopular
$27.95
4.8 (1,744)10% off

Thirty inches of handle keeps hands well back from the flame while the marshmallow toasts.

Long-handled marshmallow roaster for even toasting

Get on Amazon · $27.95 — Marshmallow Roasterwhat to look for & our pick →

Fire extinguisher or water bucket

Stays within arm's reach of the table the entire time the fire is lit.

Get on Amazon · $19.97 — Fire extinguisher or water bucketdetails & deals →

Firepit fuel specified in your manual

Firepit fuel specified in your manual

Essential

The fire runs on it, and only the type your manual names is safe to use.

RELATED GEAR GUIDE

10 Pieces of Cyanotype Sun Printing Gear Worth Buying in 2026

Practical picks, real prices · Creative Arts

As an Amazon Associate, IRL Sidequests earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Prices and availability are subject to change. The price shown at checkout on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.

Where this one naturally leads next.

Backyard BBQ Smoke-Off - Creative Arts quest

Backyard BBQ Smoke-Off

Today, you're going to turn your backyard into a legitimate BBQ competition where smoke rings and bark quality determine the champion.

Transform your backyard into a smoky competition arena where you'll master the ancient art of low-and-slow cooking. You'll prepare multiple proteins and sides simultaneously, experimenting with different wood chips, rubs, and temperatures to create bark-crusted brisket, fall-off-the-bone ribs, or perfectly tender pulled pork. Invite fellow grill enthusiasts to blind-taste your creations, score each dish on smoke ring depth, bark texture, and flavor complexity, then crown a pitmaster. This isn't just grilling—it's controlling fire, smoke, and time to transform tough cuts into competition-worthy BBQ.

2+ hoursGear from $220
Intermediate
View Quest
Backyard BBQ Smoke-Off
Collaborative Feast Cooking Session - Social & Community quest

Collaborative Feast Cooking Session

Everybody teaches a dish, everybody swaps jobs

Gather four to eight friends in your kitchen and cook a four-part meal together, swapping stations every 45 minutes so everyone teaches and learns something. Three to four hours later you sit down to fresh pasta, a slow-simmered main, a bright salad and dessert you all made.

3-4 hoursFamilyGear from $99
Intermediate
View Quest
Collaborative Feast Cooking Session
Craft Night Social Making: Build Community Through Hands-On Creation - Social & Community quest

Craft Night Social Making: Build Community Through Hands-On Creation

Hands busy, snacks out, and suddenly everyone's talking.

Invite six or eight people over, put one simple craft project on the table, and spend an afternoon making the same thing together. Everyone leaves with something they built, a few new jokes, and a reason to come back next month. Snacks on a lazy susan, music low, nobody rushing.

2-3 hours per sessionFamilyGear from $46
Beginner
View Quest
Craft Night Social Making: Build Community Through Hands-On Creation

Not this one?

Get a different side quest in 30 seconds

Tell the generator how much time you have, who you're with, and your mood — it picks from 500+ quests like this one.

Try the real life side quest generator

Or browse the full list of real-life side quest ideas.

Your weekend just got more interesting.

One new adventure idea every Thursday — plus this quest saved to your account. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy policy.